Not Our Kind Of Democracy
Monday, December 11th, 2006Talk about a continuing failure in Iraq!
In case you needed to be convinced the U.S. has been unable to install an American-style democracy in Iraq, look no further than recent news from the Iraqi Board of Supreme Audit.
(Doesn’t that sound more impressive than the Congressional Budget Office?)
Anyway, according to Abdulbasit Turki Saeed, president of the board, the government has spent only about a 15% of the oil revenues allocated for 2006.
Nationwide, a mere 20% of the entire capital budget has been expended. 20%!
This is NOT even an effective American puppet government at work.
It’s nearly 2007, and the pitiful Iraqi bureaucracy is falling asleep on the job! What kind of example are they setting for future U.S. occupied nations?
Heck, here in the good old U.S.A., we pride ourselves on spending every available penny BEFORE the revenue even comes in. In fact, we spend money every day that will NEVER come in unless we raise taxes or cut benefits.
Year-end “emergency” resolutions and spending bills are time-honored American legislative events.
You would think the U.S.-approved government in Iraq would have already incorporated some of our more venerated traditions into their own so-called democracy!
Why, according to the Iraq Study Group’s bipartisan report of last week, many ministries can do little more than pay salaries, let alone actually fund any necessary projects.
Well, at least that sounds American.
Hussain al-Shahristani, the Iraqi oil minister, claimed he could spend substantially more of this year’s budget if he could resolve administrative bottlenecks, citing Finance Ministry delays in authorizing payments.
I am happy to see that a few Iraqis, if they haven’t yet mastered the art of spending it, have become somewhat proficient in passing the buck.
The problem apparently stems from an unwillingness on the part of officials in the Iraqi Finance Ministry to actually put their names on documents authorizing any but the most basic payments.
You see, following a tremendously corrupt period (more or less since the U.S. arrived), which saw many government bureaucrats arrested and jailed, sweeping anti-corruption laws were adopted.
Now their old colleagues-in-crime, who remain in place throughout the government, are not wont to take any chances – like signing their names to contracts for food, water, electricity, or other bothersome needs.
Once again, the Iraqis have missed the boat on proper “nation building.”
When problems of corruption arise in the U.S. government, the general rule is to investigate thoroughly and at length, decide whether or not laws, rules or regulations have been violated, and then changes the laws, rules and regulations post-haste, or simply announce the officials in question were exempt from prosecution or legal recourse.
Once in a while, if the American public is sufficiently piqued, an official “rebuke” is in order.
Once in an even greater while, if the crimes are so blatant, the scapegoat so obvious, and the stars and election cycles are aligned just so, a politician may receive a short term in a pleasant, not particularly secure, facility.
Even so, the miscreant will undoubtedly be re-elected to some other office once penance is paid, or sufficient campaign contributions are made, perhaps even while still incarcerated.
Rathi al-Rathi, the head of Iraq’s Commission on Public Integrity, has been privately accused by Western and Iraqi officials of zealotry, political bias and other failings.
Mr. Rathi actually wants to try to insure his country is governed on the up-and-up. He obviously has been unduly influenced by an over-active conscience, and any radical, unrealistic fantasies perpetuated by the likes of Frank Capra, a well-known communist sympathizer.
Thankfully, Iraqi Prime Minister Nuri Kamal al-Maliki, appears ready put an end to this Rathi/Integrity nonsense, by accusing him and the commission of mishandling or misappropriating hundreds of thousands of dollars. The prime minister obviously has been paying some attention to U.S. tactics and strategies.
That bright spot aside, I can’t help but be frustrated by our inability to spread genuine American values around the globe, especially in these troubling times, and in countries we occupy!
I am somewhat mollified, however, by the Iraqis’ appreciation for well-armed militias. At least they’ve gotten that much right.
But until they start spending the billions of dollars just gathering dust in some “lock-box” somewhere, it appears we will need to maintain our presence in Iraq until such time as those stubborn people abandon their backward ways.
